Is Etsy Legit? How To Buy And Sell On Etsy Safely in 2024

Reading Time: 11 minutes

When it comes to online shopping and selling, we often wonder, “is this site trustworthy?” With the rise of online marketplaces, one name that comes up frequently is Etsy.

“Is Etsy legit?” you may ask. You’re not alone in seeking the answer to this question.

This article aims to address this concern while guiding you through the process of buying and selling safely on Etsy.

Quick Takeaways:

  1. Etsy Legitimacy: Etsy is a legitimate online marketplace established in 2005, boasting millions of users globally and a reputation for unique, handcrafted goods.
  2. Safety Measures: Etsy has robust safety measures for both buyers and sellers, including secure payment options, a review and rating system, and a dispute resolution process.
  3. Buyer Tips:
    • Check Seller Profiles: Gain insights into a seller’s reliability through their profile and reviews.
    • Use Secure Payments: Stick to Etsy’s secure payment options for a worry-free transaction.
    • Effective Communication: Directly message sellers for any queries or concerns.
    • Utilize Dispute Resolution: In case of issues, Etsy’s resolution center is available for assistance.
  4. Seller Tips:
    • Create Secure Profiles: Build trust by providing accurate information in your seller profile.
    • Optimize Product Listings: Clear descriptions and accurate prices enhance the buying experience.
    • Understand Etsy Fees: Familiarize yourself with Etsy’s fees to price products appropriately.
    • Prioritize Communication: Prompt and polite responses to buyer inquiries contribute to a positive seller experience.
  5. Common Buyer Mistakes:
    • Thorough Product Description Reading: Avoid disappointment by carefully reading product descriptions, including dimensions and materials.
    • Check Seller Reviews: Assess seller reliability through reviews and ratings.
    • Shipping Policies Awareness: Be aware of shipping costs and time frames to prevent unexpected surprises.
  6. Common Seller Mistakes:
    • Complete Shop Policies: Avoid disputes by filling out shop policies, including shipping and returns.
    • High-Quality Photos: Use clear, high-resolution photos to accurately represent your products.
    • Optimize for Search: Improve shop visibility by using appropriate keywords in titles, descriptions, and tags.

Is Etsy Legit?

screenshot of etsy landing page

Etsy is an online marketplace where folks of any age can sell and buy unique, handcrafted goods and vintage items. Established in 2005, Etsy quickly grew to become a go-to site for those looking to buy or sell unique wares.

Today, it boasts millions of sellers and buyers from around the world. Its long-standing history and large user base serve as proof that Etsy is indeed a legit online marketplace.

In fact, well-known media outlets have regularly praised Etsy for its community of talented creators. It’s a favorite among many shoppers looking for unique gifts or personalized items. While there are always exceptions, the vast majority of transactions on Etsy are successful and hassle-free.

Understanding Etsy’s Safety Measures

Ensuring safety while shopping or selling online is crucial. Etsy has in place several safety measures to protect both buyers and sellers.

For buyers, Etsy offers secure payment options. This means you can make a purchase without worry. It also has a review and rating system in place, allowing you to judge the reliability of a seller based on previous buyers’ experiences. If a problem arises, Etsy has a dispute resolution process to help resolve the issue.

For sellers, Etsy provides a secure transaction process and a seller protection policy. Sellers also have access to a supportive community. If a problem occurs, Etsy provides resources to help resolve it.

Earn Money Selling Printables on Etsy - FREE Workshop

If you're looking for the perfect side hustle to tap into your creativity, selling printables on Etsy could be your golden ticket! 

This is for you, even if you have minimal time, experience or money. Join students who collectively have generated over $500,000 in selling printables on Etsy in the last year alone.

Join this FREE workshop and learn how to get started today!

How to Buy Safely on Etsy

Here are some pointers to buy safely on Etsy:

  • Check the seller profile and reviews: These can provide valuable insights about the seller’s reliability.
  • Use secure payment options: Etsy supports safe and secure payment methods. Avoid transactions outside these options.
  • Communicate with the seller: If you have queries or concerns, it’s best to message the seller directly.
  • Dispute resolution: If there’s an issue with the purchase, you can use Etsy’s resolution center to get help.

How to Sell Safely on Etsy

If you’re looking to sell on Etsy, here’s what you need to know:

  • Create a secure seller profile: Providing accurate information builds trust with your customers.
  • List your products correctly: Provide clear descriptions and accurate prices for your items.
  • Understand Etsy’s fees and charges: Etsy charges fees for listing, transactions, and payments. Knowing these can help you price your products correctly.
  • Maintain good communication with buyers: Respond to queries promptly and politely. Good communication can often resolve potential problems.

Like any online marketplace, Etsy isn’t immune to scams. However, awareness can be your best defense. Some common scams include non-delivery of items, counterfeit goods, and phishing attempts. It’s important to report such issues to Etsy so they can take necessary action.

sell rock climbing art on etsy

Is Etsy Legit? Buyer Tips

Purchasing items on Etsy can be a rewarding experience, especially when you can find unique and handmade items directly from sellers around the world.

However, buyers can sometimes make mistakes that may affect their shopping experience. Here are seven common mistakes and how they can be avoided:

1. Not Reading the Product Description Thoroughly

Some buyers skim through or ignore the product descriptions and then end up disappointed when the item doesn’t meet their expectations. To avoid this, always take the time to carefully read the full product description.

This includes details about the item’s dimensions, materials, and care instructions.

2. Ignoring Seller Reviews

Before buying from a seller, check their reviews and ratings. This can provide valuable insight into their reliability, product quality, and customer service. A common mistake is to purchase from a seller without checking their feedback.

3. Not Checking Shipping Policies and Costs

Some buyers overlook shipping costs and time frames, leading to unexpected costs or delays. Always review the seller’s shipping policy, costs, and estimated delivery dates before making a purchase.

4. Failing to Communicate with the Seller

If you have any questions or specific requirements, it’s best to communicate with the seller before placing an order. Many misunderstandings and mistakes can be avoided with clear and open communication.

5. Not Understanding Return and Refund Policies

Some buyers don’t review the seller’s return and refund policy before purchasing. It’s essential to understand these policies to avoid confusion or disappointment in case the item isn’t what you expected.

6. Overlooking Custom Fees and Taxes

If you’re buying from a seller in a different country, there may be customs fees or taxes when the item enters your country. It’s the buyer’s responsibility to cover these costs, so always keep this in mind when purchasing internationally.

7. Assuming All Products are Handmade

While Etsy is known for its handmade items, not all products sold on the platform are handmade. Some are vintage items, while others are craft supplies. Some sellers also offer manufactured items. Read the product descriptions carefully to ensure you’re getting what you expect.

Avoiding these common mistakes can greatly enhance your shopping experience on Etsy. Remember, when in doubt, reach out to the seller for clarification.

Is Etsy Legit? Seller Tips

Being an Etsy seller can be a rewarding experience, but it can also come with its own set of challenges. Here are nine common mistakes Etsy sellers often make and how they can be avoided:

1. Not Filling Out the Shop Policies

Some sellers forget to complete their shop policies, leading to confusion and potential disputes with customers. To avoid this, be sure to fill out your policies section, including shipping, returns, exchanges, and custom orders.

2. Using Poor-Quality Photos

Pictures are the only way a customer can see the item before buying online. Poor quality photos, lack of detail, or misleading images can lead to unsatisfied customers. Be sure to use high-resolution photos that accurately represent your product.

3. Ignoring SEO Practices

Some sellers neglect to optimize their listings for search, making their products harder to find. Be sure to use appropriate keywords in your titles, descriptions, and tags to improve your shop’s visibility.

4. Inadequate Customer Service

Customer service is key to earning positive reviews and repeat customers. Be responsive to customer inquiries, and handle any issues promptly and professionally.

5. Underpricing or Overpricing Items

Pricing can be tricky. If you price your items too low, you may not cover your costs or make a profit. If they’re too high, you may not make any sales. Research similar products to ensure your pricing is competitive and also sustainable for your business.

6. Not Factoring in All Costs

Some sellers overlook costs like shipping, packaging, or transaction fees when pricing their products, which can eat into their profits. Be sure to factor in all costs when pricing your items to ensure profitability.

7. Skipping Product Descriptions

A lack of detail in your product descriptions can lead to customers not fully understanding what they’re buying. Make sure you include details about size, materials, usage, etc., in your product descriptions.

8. Not Understanding Etsy’s Fees

Some sellers don’t fully understand the fees associated with selling on Etsy, which can lead to surprises when they receive their bill. Familiarize yourself with Etsy’s fee structure to avoid unexpected costs.

9. Not Having a Clear Branding Strategy

It’s important for your shop to have a clear identity. This includes your shop name, banner, logo, product packaging, and the overall feel of your shop. A clear branding strategy helps attract and retain customers.

Avoiding these common mistakes can greatly enhance your Etsy selling experience. Remember, always aim to provide a clear, honest, and professional approach to your business.

etsy shop - website example

Evaluating Etsy: Pros and Cons for a Safe and Informed Shopping Experience


  1. Legitimacy and Global Reach:
    • Etsy is a well-established and globally recognized platform, offering a wide array of unique and handmade products from sellers worldwide.
  2. Secure Transactions:
    • Etsy provides a secure checkout process, ensuring that transactions are safe for buyers, with multiple payment options, making it safe to buy on the platform.
  3. Buyer Protection Measures:
    • With Etsy’s buyer protection policies, customers are assured of a secure shopping experience, fostering confidence in the safety to buy from various Etsy shops.
  4. Transparent Review System:
    • Etsy’s review system allows buyers to make informed decisions based on the experiences of previous customers, enhancing the trustworthiness of Etsy sellers’ shops.
  5. Supportive Community:
    • The Etsy community is known for its support and collaboration among sellers, contributing to a positive environment for both buyers and sellers.
  6. Effective Messaging System:
    • Etsy’s messaging system facilitates direct communication between buyers and sellers, ensuring a clear and open channel for inquiries or concerns.
  7. Seller Accountability:
    • Etsy holds sellers accountable through its review system, encouraging sellers to maintain the quality and reliability of their Etsy stores.


  1. Potential for Fraud:
    • While Etsy has measures in place, instances of fraud can still occur, emphasizing the importance of due diligence when selecting Etsy sellers.
  2. Varied Seller Quality:
    • The quality of Etsy sellers can vary, and not all sellers adhere to the same standards, requiring buyers to thoroughly check Etsy sellers’ reviews.
  3. Complex Fee Structure:
    • Understanding Etsy’s fees can be challenging for new sellers, requiring careful consideration to ensure pricing is competitive and sustainable for their Etsy store.
  4. Possible Etsy Scams:
    • While rare, Etsy scams, such as non-delivery or counterfeit goods, can occur, underscoring the importance of reporting suspicious activity and relying on Etsy’s dispute resolution system.
  5. Not All Products Are Handmade:
    • Etsy, despite its reputation for handmade items, also allows the sale of vintage and manufactured products, requiring buyers to carefully read product descriptions to ensure they align with their expectations.

Overall, while Etsy is a legit store and generally safe to buy from, users should remain vigilant and utilize Etsy’s safety features to have a secure and satisfying experience on the platform.

Is Etsy Legit? – Summary

The question can be answered confidently with a “yes.” However, like any online marketplace, users should take precautions when buying or selling.

By understanding Etsy’s safety measures, checking seller profiles, communicating effectively, and being aware of potential Etsy scams, you can enjoy a safe and satisfying Etsy experience.

Remember, the internet offers countless opportunities, but it’s essential to navigate it wisely. Happy shopping and selling on Etsy!

Earn Money Selling Printables on Etsy - FREE Workshop

If you're looking for the perfect side hustle to tap into your creativity, selling printables on Etsy could be your golden ticket! 

This is for you, even if you have minimal time, experience or money. Join students who collectively have generated over $500,000 in selling printables on Etsy in the last year alone.

Join this FREE workshop and learn how to get started today!

Is Etsy Legit? Frequently Asked Questions

Can you make money on Etsy?

Yes, many individuals and businesses make a significant income by selling their products on Etsy. However, success can depend on various factors such as the quality and uniqueness of your products, the competitiveness of your pricing, your marketing efforts, and customer service skills.

How does Etsy pay sellers?

Etsy pays sellers through Etsy Payments, which is their primary method for payment transactions. Sellers can receive their payments via several methods such as bank transfers, cheques, PayPal, or other options based on their location.

What is Etsy’s return policy?

Return policies on Etsy are determined by individual sellers. Some sellers accept returns, exchanges, and cancellations, but others do not. Buyers should check the return policy of each shop before making a purchase.

Are all products on Etsy handmade?

While Etsy is known for handmade goods, not all products sold on the site are handmade. Etsy also allows sellers to offer vintage items (at least 20 years old) and craft supplies.

How do I contact Etsy customer service?

You can contact Etsy customer service through their help center. They offer support via email and sometimes phone calls for more urgent issues. You can also find various self-help resources on their site.

Does Etsy offer free shipping?

Shipping policies are set by individual sellers on Etsy. Some sellers offer free shipping on their items, either on all products or when your purchase exceeds a certain amount.

Is Etsy good for beginners?

Etsy is known for being a user-friendly platform which makes it a good option for beginners looking to start selling their handmade or vintage goods. There are numerous resources provided for Etsy shop ideas, as well as community forums, to help new sellers get started.

Can I trust all sellers on Etsy?

When considering the questions ‘is Etsy legit?’, while Etsy as a platform is legit, the reliability of individual sellers can vary. It’s important to review the seller’s ratings and reviews, and communicate with the seller directly if you have any concerns before making a purchase.

Can Etsy sellers see my credit card information?

No, Etsy sellers do not have access to your credit card information. When you make a purchase, your payment is processed securely through Etsy Payments, and your credit card information is never shared with sellers.

Can I sell digital products on Etsy?

Yes, Etsy allows sellers to offer digital items, such as printables, digital art, or PDF patterns. After purchasing a digital item, the buyer can download the file directly from their Etsy account.

How do I start selling on Etsy?

Starting your e-commerce business by selling on Etsy is a straightforward process. You’ll need to create an Etsy account, set up your shop, list your items with detailed descriptions and photos, and set up payment and shipping methods.

How long does shipping take on Etsy?

Shipping times on Etsy depend on various factors including the location of the seller, the destination, and the shipping method used. Each seller on Etsy sets their own shipping methods and times. Buyers can view estimated shipping times on the product listing page.

Is it safe to sell vintage items on Etsy?

Yes, it is safe to sell vintage items on Etsy. Etsy is a popular platform for selling items that are at least 20 years old. However, it’s important to accurately describe and photograph your items, and to price them competitively.

What if an item doesn’t arrive or doesn’t match its description?

If an item doesn’t arrive or doesn’t match its description, you can open a case with Etsy’s dispute resolution system. Before doing this, it’s recommended that you contact the seller directly to try to resolve the issue.

Can I cancel an order on Etsy?

The ability to cancel an order depends on the seller’s policy and whether the item has already been shipped. It’s recommended to contact the seller directly to inquire about cancellations.

What happens if I receive a damaged item from Etsy?

If you receive a damaged item, you should first contact the seller to report the problem. Many sellers are willing to replace the item or offer a refund. If the seller doesn’t resolve the issue, you can open a case with Etsy.

How often does Etsy pay sellers?

Etsy deposits payments into sellers’ bank accounts at least once a week, but sellers can choose to get paid daily, every two weeks, or monthly. It may take a few days for the payment to be processed and appear in your bank account.

Does Etsy guarantee purchases?

While Etsy doesn’t offer a direct purchase guarantee, it does provide a dispute resolution system if your item doesn’t arrive or doesn’t match the description. The platform encourages buyers to contact sellers directly to resolve any issues before escalating to a formal dispute.

How are Etsy fees calculated?

Etsy charges a listing fee, a transaction fee, and a payment processing fee. The listing fee is a flat rate per item, while the transaction fee is a percentage of the selling price. The payment processing fee varies by location and is a percentage of the total amount paid by the buyer, including shipping and tax.

Can I sell internationally on Etsy?

Yes, you can sell your products to customers around the world on Etsy. When setting up shipping options for your products, you can choose to offer international shipping. Be sure to research shipping costs to ensure you price your products appropriately.

Is it safe to buy from Etsy?

Yes, Etsy is a legit store, and it is generally safe to buy from the Etsy platform. With secure payment options and Etsy’s buyer protection measures, customers can confidently explore and purchase unique items from various Etsy shops.

What is the downside on Etsy?

While Etsy offers a diverse marketplace, there are some downsides to consider. Users should be cautious of potential fraud or scams, varying seller quality, and may find Etsy’s customer support to be limited in addressing certain issues.

Is Etsy a Chinese Company?

No, Etsy is not a Chinese company. It is an American e-commerce platform founded in 2005. Etsy connects buyers and sellers globally, providing a platform for individuals and businesses to showcase and sell their handmade, vintage, and unique products.

Is Etsy a reputable company to deal with?

Yes, Etsy is considered a reputable company in the e-commerce industry. It has a long-standing history, a large and engaged community, and has received positive recognition for its unique offerings and support for creators. However, as with any online platform, users should exercise caution and adhere to safe buying and selling practices.

About the author

Disclaimer: Please note this post may contain affiliate links, from which, at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission. Also as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I only recommend products and services I’ve used or would use myself. If you choose to purchase from any of my links, thanks so much for your support! 😊

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap